top of page
Search

Basmati Rice – The Pride of Punjab & Haryana and the Battle for GI Recognition

1. Name & Origin

Basmati Rice, often referred to as the "Champagne of Rice," is a long-grain aromatic rice variety grown predominantly in Punjab, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Delhi, Uttarakhand, Uttar Pradesh, and Jammu & Kashmir. Known for its fragrant aroma, fluffy texture, and slender grains that elongate when cooked, Basmati has been cultivated in the Indo-Gangetic Plains for centuries.

The name "Basmati" is derived from the Sanskrit words "Vas" (aroma) and "Mati" (ingrained from the origin), symbolizing the rice’s distinct fragrance and geographical uniqueness.

To protect its authenticity and prevent misbranding, the Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority (APEDA) of India applied for a Geographical Indication (GI) tag in 2008, which was finally granted in 2016. However, Basmati’s GI status has been at the center of major international disputes, particularly between India, Pakistan, and foreign entities attempting to monopolize the name.


Image Credit: IndiaMart
Image Credit: IndiaMart

2. Unique Features

Basmati Rice stands out for its distinctive cooking properties, aroma, and heritage-linked characteristics.

Key Features:

  • Extra-Long Grains – Slender, fine-textured grains that elongate more than twice their original length after cooking.

  • Distinct Aroma – Naturally infused with a sweet, nutty fragrance due to the presence of 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline.

  • Soft, Fluffy Texture – The rice remains non-sticky and light when cooked.

  • High Nutritional Value – Rich in fiber, essential vitamins, and minerals, with a low glycemic index.

  • Traditional Cultivation Methods – Grown using age-old farming techniques in the Himalayan foothills.


3. International Disputes Over Basmati Rice GI

The GI protection of Basmati rice has sparked several legal battles, involving India, Pakistan, and foreign corporations.

Case 1: The RiceTec Patent Dispute (USA, 1997-2001)

  • In 1997, RiceTec Inc., a Texas-based company, applied for a patent on Basmati-like rice varieties and attempted to trademark names like "Texmati," "Kasmati," and "Jasmati."

  • The company falsely marketed its rice as "American Basmati," threatening India’s monopoly on the Basmati brand.

  • India and Pakistan strongly opposed the patent, arguing that Basmati is a traditional subcontinental variety that cannot be patented by a foreign company.

  • After legal proceedings, in 2001, the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) ruled in favor of India, rejecting RiceTec’s exclusive claim.


Case 2: The India-Pakistan Basmati GI Dispute (EU, 2018-Present)

  • In 2016, the European Union (EU) granted India’s application for a GI tag for Basmati rice, preventing foreign countries from using the term.

  • In 2018, India applied for Protected Geographical Indication (PGI) status in the EU to secure sole ownership.

  • Pakistan opposed India’s claim, arguing that Basmati is a shared heritage and that Pakistani Basmati rice also meets the traditional quality standards.

  • In 2024, the EU ruled that both India and Pakistan can sell rice under the "Basmati" label, preventing India from obtaining exclusive rights.


Case 3: Rejections of India’s GI Claim (Australia & New Zealand, 2024)

  • Australia and New Zealand rejected India’s trademark application for Basmati, ruling that the name could not be monopolized by one country.

  • The ruling highlights growing challenges in global GI protection, particularly for products with shared heritage across borders.


Image Credit: KNN India.
Image Credit: KNN India.

4. Impact of GI (Geographical Indication) Status

The GI status for Basmati rice has had profound economic, legal, and cultural implications.

Economic Impact - India exports over 5.2 million metric tons of Basmati rice annually, generating over $5.8 billion in revenue. Top export destinations include Saudi Arabia, Iran, UAE, Iraq, USA, and the UK. The GI tag protects Indian farmers by ensuring premium pricing for authentic Basmati rice.


Legal & Diplomatic Impact - The GI dispute has influenced trade agreements, WTO discussions, and bilateral negotiations between India and Pakistan. International rejections of India’s GI exclusivity claim have led to renewed legal battles and appeals.


Sustainability Impact - The GI status has encouraged the adoption of eco-friendly cultivation techniques, reducing chemical pesticide use. Organic Basmati farming initiatives have gained momentum to meet strict European food safety regulations.



5. Challenges & Future Concerns

Despite its GI protection, Basmati rice faces several hurdles in maintaining its authenticity and market dominance.

Key Challenges:

  • Counterfeit Basmati Varieties – Many non-GI rice varieties are mislabeled as Basmati in markets like the USA, UK, and Middle East.

  • Pakistan’s Ongoing GI Claims – The EU’s dual-recognition approach may dilute India’s exclusive branding rights.

  • Madhya Pradesh’s GI Claim (India’s Internal Dispute) – The state of Madhya Pradesh is lobbying to include its rice under the Basmati GI, a move opposed by Punjab, Haryana, and APEDA.

  • Climate Change & Water Scarcity – Declining water levels in Punjab and Haryanathreaten Basmati’s long-term production.



6. How to Identify Authentic Basmati Rice

GI Certification – Look for APEDA’s official GI certification and branding.

Aroma Test – Genuine Basmati has a distinct floral fragrance, unlike ordinary long-grain rice.

Grain Length & Expansion – Authentic Basmati grains elongate over twice their original length when cooked.

Region of Origin – Ensure the rice originates from Punjab, Haryana, Uttarakhand, or other GI-approved regions.

Packaging & Labeling – Look for export certification stamps, especially for EU and Middle Eastern markets.



7. Fun Facts

  • Basmati rice grains elongate up to 2.5 times their raw size, unlike any other rice variety.

  • It takes 140–160 days to grow Basmati rice, making it one of the longest-maturing rice crops.

  • The world’s most expensive Basmati rice brand, "Kohinoor Extra Long," costs up to ₹2,000 per kg.

  • Basmati rice exports account for nearly 70% of India’s total rice export revenue.



References:

  1. The Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act 1999 (India)

  2. Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority (APEDA), ‘Basmati Rice and its Geographical Indication Status’ (Government of India, 2016) https://apeda.gov.in/apedawebsite/ accessed 24 February 2025

  3. European Commission, ‘Decision on Basmati Rice GI Dispute Between India and Pakistan’ (European Union Intellectual Property Office, 2024) https://euipo.europa.euaccessed 24 February 2025

  4. World Trade Organization (WTO), ‘Dispute Settlement: Basmati Rice GI Dispute’ (WTO, 2023) https://wto.orgaccessed 24 February 2025

  5. ‘Basmati Rice: A Long-Standing GI Battle Between India and Pakistan’ The Hindu Business Line (6 January 2024) https://www.thehindubusinessline.com accessed 24 February 2025

  6. Anup Kumar, ‘The Legal Battle Over Basmati Rice: India’s Quest for GI Protection’(2023) Journal of Intellectual Property Rights 28(3) 187 https://nopr.niscpr.res.in accessed 24 February 2025

  7. Priya Mishra, ‘India’s Basmati GI Dispute in the EU: Implications for Future Trade’(2023) Economic and Political Weekly 58(12) 94 https://epw.in accessed 24 February 2025

  8. ‘The RiceTec Controversy: How India Fought for Basmati’s Identity’ Times of India (20 August 2023) https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com accessed 24 February 2025

  9. ‘Basmati Rice: Trademark Rejections in Australia and New Zealand’ Reuters (5 February 2024) https://www.reuters.com accessed 24 February 2025

  10. ‘Climate Change Threatens Punjab’s Basmati Fields’ BBC News India (10 December 2023) https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india accessed 24 February 2025


コメント

bottom of page